Pilates is taught in gyms, leisure centres, church halls and living rooms, and the word covers a wide range of classes whether you’re looking in Harpenden, Luton, St Albans or your local leisure centre. Two people who both say they do Pilates can have done quite different things. So what is Pilates? And is everything that is called Pilates actually Pilates?
TLDR: Classical or authentic Pilates is a comprehensive, structured system of movement using Joseph Pilates’ original exercise sequences and specialised apparatus (like Reformers, Chairs, and Barrels). Unlike generalised gym mat classes, studio-based Classical or authentic Pilates focuses on individual progression, full-body integration, and tailored equipment feedback under high-level instructor guidance.
Where it comes from
Joseph Pilates called his method Contrology, and he designed the equipment that goes with it, including the Reformer, the Cadillac, the Wunda Chair and the Ladder Barrel. In 1945 he published “Return to Life Through Contrology”, which describes 34 mat exercises. These exercises were inspired by Joseph’s observations of gymnastics, yoga, animal movement and much more. After he died, Contrology became known as Pilates. Many of his students went on to teach, and each of them passed on the work in their own way. Those who were directly taught by Joe became known as The Elders. Romana Kryzanowska and Jay Grimes are Elders, amongst others.
What classical means
Strictly speaking, classical Pilates refers to teachers who trained in the lineage of Romana Kryzanowska. At Pilates Barns, we prefer the word authentic for what we do, meaning close to how Joseph taught (as we understand it), but classical is the term used more often when describing the differences between Pilates.
At Pilates Barns we teach from Joseph Pilates’ work and the work of the various Elders, and we bring in archival exercises where we can. We also teach with current movement science and research in mind, meaning our classes aren’t a museum piece, but a living, effective workout built for modern bodies. What stays fixed is the mat and Reformer orders, which take the body through a planned sequence of exercises instead of being rebuilt each week.
The mat work and the apparatus belong together. The Reformer is the piece most people have heard of, but each apparatus trains different things, and a teacher can move you between them as you progress. Movement is controlled and continuous, with breathing often coordinated to it. Our studios have all of the different pieces of equipment and our clients will get to use all of it.
Contemporary Pilates
From the 1980s onwards, many teachers adapted the method. Some worked with physiotherapists and rehabilitation specialists, and they changed exercises, reordered sequences and added props. This is usually called contemporary or modern Pilates.
How it differs from a gym class
Most gym Pilates is mat-based and uses small props such as a ball or a band. Some gyms do run Reformer classes, so check the timetable. A mat class is a good way to learn the basic shapes, and it costs less and is easier to fit into a gym membership.
The main differences are in four areas.
Equipment. A full equipment studio gives you the springs and resistance of the apparatus, which change how an exercise feels and let the teacher adjust it to your body. Our Reformers are built to Joseph’s design, with four springs of equal tension, no risers on the straps and leather straps. We believe this makes the exercises work the body as he intended. Modern additions, such as springs of different tensions and high risers on the straps, change the tension, dimension and angles of the exercises, and so the feel of them changes noticeably.
Structure. Gym classes are often built around a theme, such as core, stretch or “Bums & Tums”, and the content changes from week to week. In our studio you will get a whole body workout every time. Whilst the mat and reformer orders stay consistent, new exercises will be added in as you progress. The repetition of exercises shows your progress over time and the new exercises add challenge and strength.
Group size and attention. Gym classes tend to be larger so the instructor is teaching to whoever turns up. In a studio setting the teacher can correct individuals more easily, we get to know each of you, your struggles and challenges, what you find easy and what is happening in the rest of your life because your body is the result of many things, not just your exercises!
Teacher training. All of our teachers have completed more than a year of comprehensive teacher training, usually over 600 hours. Qualifications across the industry vary a lot, from short weekend courses to full diplomas, so it’s worth asking any teacher where they trained and for how long.
Is everything that is called Pilates actually Pilates?
In my opinion and that of many classical or authentic teachers I know, the answer is no. Just because a studio says they do Pilates it doesn’t make it true. Some big chains train their teachers on a short course specific to that chain. Some “reformer studios” are just that – studios with reformers and no other piece of equipment. Is that Pilates? Maybe. However, more likely it is just exercises on a reformer with no reference to the original order or repertoire. Sure, these places might offer a good workout but for me, it is not Pilates.
Which one to try
If you want a convenient class alongside your gym sessions, a gym mat class serves a purpose. But if you want to learn a complete, progressive system under the guidance of specialist teachers, a dedicated studio setting makes all the difference.
Ready to try Pilates at Pilates Barns?
Our 5-Week Beginner Course provides an introduction to the Classical system in a supportive, small-group environment.
Locations: The Pilates Barns Luton Hoo Estate & St Albans
£99
